Bold promise, failed implementation, exempt your friends

It’s not just the healthcare mess, it’s green jobs, shovel-ready stimulus, the ‘reset’ in foreign policy, closing Gitmo, climate change, bailouts…  The M.O. is the same: bold promise, failed implementation, exempt your friends.

Why not exempt Congress from Obamacare?  President Obama has already granted waivers to his cronies.

Writing in The New York Times, David Brooks says there’s Health Chaos Ahead

I’ve been talking with a bipartisan bunch of health care experts, trying to get a sense of exactly how bad things are. In my conversations with this extremely well-informed group of providers, academics and former government officials, I’d say there is a minority, including some supporters of the law, who think the whole situation is a complete disaster. They predict Obamacare will collapse and do serious damage to the underlying health system.

But the clear majority, including some of the law’s opponents, believe that we’re probably in for a few years of shambolic messiness, during which time everybody will scramble and adjust, and eventually we will settle down to a new normal.

What nobody can predict is how health care chaos will interact with the political system. There’s a good chance that Republicans will be able to use unhappiness with what is already an unpopular law to win back the Senate in 2014. Controlling both houses of Congress, they will be in a good position to alter, though not repeal, the program.

The law’s biggest defenders will then become insurance companies and health care corporations. Having spent billions of dollars adapting to the new system, they are not going to want to see it repealed or replaced.

The experts talk about the problems that lie ahead in cascades…  [structural cascade, technical cascade, cost cascade (“Nearly everybody not in the employ of the administration agrees this law does not solve the cost problem, and many of the recent regulatory decisions will send costs higher.”), adverse selection cascade, provider concentration cascade]

In other words, more or less everything we critics predicted.  But at least it’ll be free health care.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Bold promise, failed implementation, exempt your friends

  1. AndyMan says:


  2. Paul Marks says:

    Never read the New York Times, and never read David Brooks – so reading David Brooks in the New York Times violates two rules of good sense.

    As for the “new normal” – it will be costs (costs that have already been pushed sky high by previous government interventions – subsidy programs [Medicare, Medicaid, SCHIP….] and regulations – mandates and so on), being pushed beyond the reach of most people.

    Sof the govenrment will be “forced” (by its own interventions) to finance the healthcare of MOST people (at first via crony “private providers” – later, as with student loans, openly).

    Terrible health care – financed by government.

    That will be the “new normal” – accept…….

    Accept that the government will be de facto bankupt soon anyway.

    And the government will drag down the economy (civil society) with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s